Skip to content
icon-X
Close menu
Seasonal
Clothing
Tops
Bottoms
Dresses
Pajamas
SALE
SALE 25% Off
Accessories
Jewelry
DIY Charm Necklace
Earring
Necklaces
Bracelets
Susan Shaw
Hair Accessories
Headbands
Travel Totes
Cosmetic Bags
Purses
Hats
Baby & Kids
Clothing
Blankets
Books
Toys
Home
Candles
Aromatique
Capri Blue
Greenleaf
Hedge Farms
Nest
Votivo
Wreaths & Door Hangers
Decor
Tea Towels
Pillows
Artwork
Ribbon
Frames
Tabletop
Drinkware
Serveware
Melamine
Linens
Tea Towels
Paper Products
Napkins
Styrofoam Cups
Paper Plates
Flex Cups
Gifts
Collegiate
Spiritual
Books
Notecards, Cards, & Journals
Men's Gifts
Puzzles
Food
Celebrations
Birthday
Wedding
Bath
Bath
Hand Soap
Men's Soap & Cologne
Mahjong Classes
Registry
Log in
instagram
Instagram
Facebook
Cart
icon-X
Close cart
Your cart is currently empty.
icon-search
Search
icon-hamburger
Site navigation
account
Log in
icon-search
Search
Cart
Seasonal
Clothing
Tops
Bottoms
Dresses
Pajamas
SALE
SALE 25% Off
Accessories
Jewelry
DIY Charm Necklace
Earring
Necklaces
Bracelets
Susan Shaw
Hair Accessories
Headbands
Travel Totes
Cosmetic Bags
Purses
Hats
Baby & Kids
Clothing
Blankets
Books
Toys
Home
Candles
Aromatique
Capri Blue
Greenleaf
Hedge Farms
Nest
Votivo
Wreaths & Door Hangers
Decor
Tea Towels
Pillows
Artwork
Ribbon
Frames
Tabletop
Drinkware
Serveware
Melamine
Linens
Tea Towels
Paper Products
Napkins
Styrofoam Cups
Paper Plates
Flex Cups
Gifts
Collegiate
Spiritual
Books
Notecards, Cards, & Journals
Men's Gifts
Puzzles
Food
Celebrations
Birthday
Wedding
Bath
Bath
Hand Soap
Men's Soap & Cologne
Mahjong Classes
Registry
Search
Search
Pause slideshow
Play slideshow
Welcome to the Gift Horse!
Our Next McCarty shipment will be in store Oct. 1st! We do not sell McCarty Pottery online.
Store Hours
Mon.-Sat. 10-5 | Sun. Closed
icon-filter
Filter
39 products
Sort
Sort
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Grosgrain Square Dinner Plate
$9.00
Gold & White Paper Charger Plate
$12.00
Wavy Gold Charger
$10.00
Panoply Scalloped Plates
from $9.00
Pink Peonies Plates (8 Pkg)
from $8.00
Birthday Hat Salad Plate
$9.00
Hydrangeas Wavy Salad Plate
$7.00
Let's Celebrate Dinner Plate
$10.00
Gold Leaf Ivory Square Dinner Plate
$8.00
Turkey & Gourds Salad Plate
$10.00
Pumpkin Bold Diecut Salad Plate
$10.00
10" Square Paper Plates Pack of 8 Classic Linen dark green
$8.00
Bright & Thankful Wavy Salad Plate
$10.00
Boo Bold Die Cut Salad Plates
$10.00
Oui Party Birthday Paper Party Cups
$10.00
Happy Birthday Felt Banner
$32.00
Party Cups - 12 oz
$10.00
Happy Birthday Felt Crown
$18.00
Birthday Double-Sided Paper Placemats
$36.00
Holly Berry Dinner Plates
$12.00
Joyful Christmas Dinner Plates
$12.00
Christmas Forest Wavy Paper Salad Plate
$10.00
Santa Salad Plate Jolly Holiday
$10.00
Wavy Salad Plate Nutcracker Christmas
$10.00
Holly Berry Salad Plates
$10.00
Joyful Christmas Salad Plates
$10.00
Holly Berry Appetizer/Dessert Bowls
$9.00
Vintage Santa Die Cut Salad Plates
$10.00
1
2
icon-chevron
Next
icon-X
"Close (esc)"
icon-X
icon-chevron
icon-X
Paper Plates
