Skip to content
  • Seasonal
  • Clothing
    • Tops
    • Bottoms
    • Dresses
    • Sale
    • Pajamas
  • Accessories
    • Jewelry
      • DIY Charm Necklace
      • Earring
      • Necklaces
      • Bracelets
      • Susan Shaw
    • Hair Accessories
      • Headbands
    • Travel Totes
    • Cosmetic Bags
    • Purses
    • Hats
  • Baby & Kids
    • Clothing
    • Blankets
    • Books
    • Toys
  • Mahjong
  • Paper Products
    • Napkins
    • Styrofoam Cups
    • Paper Plates
    • Flex Cups
  • Home
    • Candles
      • Nest
      • Aromatique
      • Capri Blue
      • Hedge Farms
      • Oxford Candle
      • Sweet Grace
      • Votivo
    • For the Kitchen
      • Serveware
      • Drinkware
      • Linens
      • Tea Towels
      • Hand Soap
    • Wreaths & Door Hangers
    • Decor
    • Tea Towels
    • Pillows
    • Artwork
    • Frames
  • Food
  • Celebrations
    • Birthday
    • Wedding
  • Bath
    • Bath
    • Hand Soap
    • Men's Soap & Cologne
  • Registry
  • Log in
  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
Cart
Subtotal
$0.00
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.
Your cart is currently empty.
icon-search Search
account Log in icon-search Search Cart
  • Seasonal
  • Clothing
    • Tops
    • Bottoms
    • Dresses
    • Sale
    • Pajamas
  • Accessories
    Jewelry
    DIY Charm Necklace
    Earring
    Necklaces
    Bracelets
    Susan Shaw
    Hair Accessories
    Headbands
    Travel Totes
    Cosmetic Bags
    Purses
    Hats
  • Baby & Kids
    • Clothing
    • Blankets
    • Books
    • Toys
  • Mahjong
  • Paper Products
    • Napkins
    • Styrofoam Cups
    • Paper Plates
    • Flex Cups
  • Home
    Candles
    Nest
    Aromatique
    Capri Blue
    Hedge Farms
    Oxford Candle
    Sweet Grace
    Votivo
    For the Kitchen
    Serveware
    Drinkware
    Linens
    Tea Towels
    Hand Soap
    Wreaths & Door Hangers
    Decor
    Tea Towels
    Pillows
    Artwork
    Frames
  • Food
  • Celebrations
    • Birthday
    • Wedding
  • Bath
    • Bath
    • Hand Soap
    • Men's Soap & Cologne
  • Registry
Welcome to the Gift Horse!
Our Next McCarty shipment will be in store Thursday Jan. 29th! We do not sell McCarty Pottery online.
Store HoursMon.-Fri. 10-6 | Sat. 10-4
27 products
Summer Styrofoam Cups
$12.00
Hotty Toddy Foam Cup
$14.00
Rocky Top Styrofoam Cup (Set of 10)
$14.00
Go Tigers Blue Cups
$14.00
Mahjong Frost Flex Cups
$18.00
Mahjong Styrofoam Cups
$14.00
Go Dawgs Styrofoam Cups (Set of 10)
$14.00
She Said Yes! Foam Cups
$14.00
Hail State Hail Foam Cup
$12.00
Birthday Cake Styrofoam Cup
$12.00
Beach Bum Styrofoam Cups
$12.00
Let's Mahj! Styrofoam Cups
$14.00
He Is Risen! Styrofoam Cups
$14.00
Call Me Old Fashioned Styrofoam Cup
$12.00
Go Mustangs! Foam Cups
$12.00
Beach Vibes Styrofoam Cups
$18.00
Lake House Styrofoam Cups
$18.00
On Boat Time Bobber Styrofoam Cups
$18.00
Beach Bum Styrofoam Cups
$18.00
Off to the Races Styrofoam Cups
$18.00
Lake Life Floats My Boat Styrofoam Cups
$18.00
Lake Water Styrofoam Cup
$18.00
Life is Better at the Lake Styrofoam Cup
$18.00
Pool Day! Styrofoam Cups
$14.00
Happy Birthday Calligraphy
$14.00
Happy Easter! Styrofoam Cup
$14.00
Tennis Double-Sided Paper Coasters
$16.00

Sign up and save

Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.

  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook

Contact Us

Info@TheGiftHorseGermantown.com

2095 Exeter Road, Suite 90, Germantown TN
901-754-8000

Store Hours

  • Monday-Friday 10:00AM-5:00PM
  • Saturday 10:00AM-4:00PM
  • Sunday: Closed

Returns, Refunds, & Exchanges

  • Privacy Policy
  • Return/Refund Policy & Instructions
  • Click Here to Start A Return
  • Search

© 2026 The Gift Horse Germantown

Powered by Shopify

Styrofoam Cups